Don and I readily admit it is a little crazy traveling 15,000 miles to see a show we have already seen twice on Broadway, and can watch anytime we want on Apple TV. When Tracey told us she saw the show in 2023, and we later learned it was coming back this summer, we figured out how to do it.
It was worth it! One of our top theater experiences.
The first time we saw the show in New York City I got to chatting with the security guard while Ashley was collecting autographs from the cast. He mentioned the real life Captain Beverly Bass has seen the musical 67 times as of THIS WRITING, it may have increased since then. I remember thinking what a musical about my life would be like.
Sitting in the audience in the 400 seat Joseph R. Smallwood Centre I wondered how many audience members were in Gander on 9/11. Director Jillian Keiley starts each performance with a small speech. She points to the thousands of crocheted squares visible throughout the theater and tells the audience she wanted this production to feel special so she asked locals to crochet their stories into squares. She hoped for 500 to line the stage. Instead she received over 2,700 squares, each with a written story telling her about that time. (Yes, the website says "over 1,000," but during her speech she cited a much larger number.)
Before each of the eight weekly performances, Jillian has a local come up and tell their first hand story about 9/11. For our performance she invited Brian, the head of the historical society and one of the few people we had already met in Gander when I emailed him to ask for a map of Come from Away spots. He said on 9/11 he was running the aviation museum (which we visited earlier that day). He waived the $3CAD admission for the plane people (admission is now still a bargain at $10CAD). He also said he would keep the museum open as late as people wanted to visit. A thousand people visited from 95 countries. He stayed open from 8:30 am to 1 am -- and hardly slept that week. He wanted to greet everyone in their native language, but couldn't figure that out quickly enough.
Jillian asked us in the spirit of the show to introduce ourselves to our neighbors. Next to me was a couple from Newfoundland. I believe he said it was their first time seeing the show. As he hogged the armrest I gave him more grace than I usually do because we had looked each other in the eye before the show started.
At the end of the show, the on the aisle asked us to pass them as they collected themselves. They, too, had been crying the entire 100 minutes.
We saw Brian again after the show and asked about specific lines, including "the river behind the Legion" -- we saw the Canadian Legion Hall and there was a street behind it. He said it was in Gambo, not Gander, and that artistic language was taken. Fair enough. He also said Gambo is really the "gayest town in Canada," so we decided to visit Gambo on our way back to St. John's.
The show was amazing. I was in tears from the first note until the last. Good tears. Therapeutic tears.
We stopped in the art gallery to admire more of the squares up close.
After the show my new friend Jillian (we met at Rosie's as we waited for dinner) asked us what we thought. It was easy to tell her how much we enjoyed it.
As we make the ten-minute walk back to the hotel it starts to drizzle. The rain poetically mirrored the ending of "Come from Away" where the weather was perfect while the CFA's (Come from Aways) were in Gander, then it started to rain. Director Jillian pulled up to us an offered a ride. We would have been fine without the ride, but it was too good of an opportunity to continue the conversation. She was also taking her friend to her hotel. There are two major hotels in town, Jane was staying at the other hotel.
Jillian shared with us how there are times when she is doing a show that the overall experience mirrors what happens on stage. This was one such time. This is her third summer of this production. The first year (the year our friend Tracey saw it was her son, Chris) the town was not ready for the influx of tourists. There were not nearly enough hotel rooms, just like in the show. By this year, the town was more prepared thanks to more AirBnB options. In 2023 when our friends saw the show they stayed in Twillingate because there were no rooms to be had in Gander.
The next morning we went to the Gander Bread Box for toutons (similar to Thomas' English Muffins). The night before we had mentioned the place to Jillian and Jane, but they were not there when we arrived. By the time we placed our order, I had a tap on my shoulder. Jillian was greeting us with a warm smile. It made the Gander experience complete.